Skip to content

West Allis man charged in wife Erica Carpenter’s 2024 death

A 45-year-old man from West Allis, Wisconsin, has been arrested and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in connection with the death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, who was 40 when she died in October 2024.

Benjamin Carpenter was taken into custody on Tuesday, November 17, following an investigation that has dramatically changed the understanding of what happened to Erica.

For nearly two years, her death appeared to be the result of a tragic accident inside the couple’s home. However, investigators now say they have established probable cause to believe that Benjamin planned and deliberately caused her death.

When police officers and firefighters arrived at the couple’s home in October 2024, they discovered Erica lying at the bottom of the basement stairs, bleeding from the head. Her husband, Benjamin, was performing CPR when emergency responders arrived.

According to the criminal complaint, Benjamin told investigators that Erica had fallen and hit her head while the two were doing laundry. He claimed that he then attempted to carry her upstairs but slipped, causing both of them to fall.

Lexo gjithashtu:  Wedding Boutique Worker Shamed Me for Being Pregnant - Karma Got Her in Less than 10 Minutes

At the time, his explanation presented the incident as an unfortunate household accident. However, questions surrounding Erica’s injuries would eventually lead investigators to examine the circumstances of her death much more closely.

“Her injuries didn’t match his account”

The medical examiner raised concerns about Benjamin’s version of events, telling police that Erica’s injuries were inconsistent with the explanation he had provided.

Further examination revealed that toxicology tests had detected both hydrocodone and a sleep medication in Erica’s system.

Her official cause of death was recorded as undetermined. However, the deputy chief medical examiner indicated that she may have died from asphyxia and noted a blunt force injury to her neck.

These findings prompted investigators to look more closely at Benjamin’s physical background and experience.

The criminal complaint states that police questioned him about his jiu-jitsu experience, including the fact that he held a black belt and was familiar with techniques such as choke holds.

Investigators considered this information as part of their efforts to understand how Erica may have sustained her injuries and whether her death could have happened in the way Benjamin described.

Lexo gjithashtu:  My MIL Invited Herself and Her Sister to My Lake House Weekend and Treated Me Like the Help Because 'Older People Deserve More Rest'

“Texts about her water”

As the investigation continued, detectives uncovered another potentially significant piece of evidence: text messages exchanged between Erica and her husband in the weeks before her death.

In the messages, Erica asked Benjamin whether he had been putting a powdery substance into her water.

Prosecutors also revealed that Benjamin had been involved in a relationship with another woman both before and after Erica’s death.

According to investigators, the woman told authorities that Benjamin had informed her during the weekend Erica died that he and his wife were planning to separate.

The financial circumstances surrounding Erica’s death also became part of the investigation.

After her death, Benjamin collected more than $200,000 through life insurance policies, as well as benefits connected to her workplace. He also promoted a GoFundMe campaign intended to help cover funeral expenses. The fundraising page has since been deactivated.

According to the criminal complaint, Benjamin told police that he was unsure about the life insurance coverage provided through Erica’s employer.

Lexo gjithashtu:  Woman who alleges Russell Brand abused her speaks out

However, her employer reportedly told investigators that Benjamin had already contacted them regarding the benefits.

Police also cited his Google searches as part of the evidence gathered during the investigation.

Together, the medical findings, messages, relationship details and financial records contributed to the case that ultimately led to Benjamin being charged.

Erica’s family wants justice

For Erica’s parents, the arrest and charges have brought a new and deeply painful development in a case they believed had been an accident.

Her family says they have been left stunned by the allegations and that their focus is now on obtaining justice for their daughter.

Benjamin Carpenter made his first court appearance on Wednesday following his arrest.

His attorney did not respond to requests for comment.

Meanwhile, police are continuing to seek information from the public as the investigation moves forward. Anyone who may have information concerning Erica Carpenter’s death is being asked to contact the West Allis Police Department.

Published inNews a